In an effort to protect consumers from what the Federal Reserve called "unfair or deceptive" practices by banks issuing credit cards, Congress passed the Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure Act in May 2009. You'd think that since passing this law, unfair, deceptive practices by credit card issuers would have abated, right? Survey says....Not even close.
According to recent report by the Pew Health Group, anti-consumer practices haven't abated in the slightest since the law was passed -- they're actually on the rise.
Credit-card lenders have been increasing fees and interest rates, raising minimum payments and lowering credit limits. Some Citi card holders, for example, have seen their credit limits cut, their interest rates skyrocket as high as 29.99%, or their cards canceled altogether. And just last month, Bank of America announced it was testing annual fees (ranging from $29 to $99) on a select number of card holders.
Pew's report found that a shocking 100 percent of the credit cards offered online by the 12 leading bank card issuers continue to include practices that will be soon be outlawed, once the Credit CARD Act takes effect. Banks surveyed include Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase, Citigroup, Wells Fargo, American Express, USAA and Capitol One.
Want a better credit card? Check out a credit union: Pew's study didn't just look at big card issuers--they took a look at credit unions as well. Their findings: although the largest 12 credit unions control only 1 percent of overall credit card lending, many of their prices are significantly lower compared to those of the largest banks. In addition, credit union penalty charges were both less frequent and less severe than those of banks. Let's take a look at some of those numbers:
Avg. interest rates on missed payment deadlines on unpaid balances:
Credit Unions: 17.9% vs. Banks: 28.8%
Average overdraft fees:
Credit unions: $20 vs. Banks: $39
According to the the Center for Responsible Lending, overdraft fees collected in 2008 have increased by 35% since 2006.
Highest interest rates (in July 2009):
Credit Unions: 13.75% vs. Banks: 21.24%
Interest rates on cards issued by Bank of America, Discover Financial Services and Capital One Financial have actually increased their interest rates by 20% in the last six months.
Making money on the backs of consumers: Though banks aren't compelled to disclose how much of their profit comes from fees, our research shows how JPMorgan Chase's bank fees comprised $3.45 billion, or 71 percent of its profit for the first half of 2009. Citigroup earned $326 million, or 95 percent of its profit, for the same period. Bank of America made 70 percent of its profit, or $5.26 billion, in bank account fees.
Although it was originally slated to take effect in staged phases--upcoming implementation dates were to be February 2010 and August 2010--U.S. lawmakers recently voted to speed up the implementation of new rules to guard against such abusive practices like those documented in Pew's study. The sooner we can hold credit card companies accountable for intentionally trapping consumers into debt from which they cannot recover, the closer we'll be towards fostering a financial system that puts long-term economic growth over short-term, expedient profits.
View Pew's full report: Still Waiting: 'Unfair or Deceptive' Credit Card Practices Continue as Americans Wait for New Reforms to Take Effect.








