SEIU - Service Employees International Union, CTW, CLC

seiu.org TAKE ACTION Stay Informed: Register for email updates. SIGN UP
  • Blog
  • Healthcare
  • Property
  • Public
  • Our Union
  • Members
  • Join Us
  • Get Local
  • Press
  • en espaƱol
  • Blog
  • Our Union
  • Press
  • Moreexpand
  • Healthcare
  • Property
  • Public
  • Members
  • Join Us
  • Get Local
  • En Español

Tag: “mental health parity legislation”

Top 10 Historical Chamber of Commerce Quotes Against Healthcare

By Kate Thomas on June 17, 2009 12:45 PM

When the U.S. Chamber of Commerce opposed early versions of the healthcare bill Tuesday, we weren't surprised. This is, after all, the same group that colorfully told the Associated Press it was "time to unload the powder and fill the musket" in their fight against health care reform. Call us cynical, but we didn't think they were planning on using that $100 million "campaign to defend the free market" on tea parties and Civil War reenactments.

The fact is, America's healthcare system is broken and all the right-wing continues to do is champion the status quo and purposely distort the reality of what fixing healthcare will mean to millions of American families. The Chamber's assault on the current bill is simply the latest in a string of attacks on common-sense healthcare reforms during the course of their existence. Here's our "Top 10."

Top 10 Historical Chamber Quotes Against Healthcare

10. U.S. Chamber of Commerce Denounced Patients' Bill of Rights As Special Interest Giveaway To Trial Lawyers. Bruce Josten, executive vice president of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce said that 2001 of the Patients' Bill of Rights "should be called the Trial Lawyers' Right to Bill...adding new mandates and expanding liability will only serve to increase insurance costs and undermine employers' ability to offer this valuable benefit." [U.S. Chamber of Commerce Press Release, 6/12/01 ]

9. U.S. Chamber Spokesman Said OSHA Is a "Blatant Denial of Fundamental Fairness." When describing the structure of the Labor Department within the Executive Branch rather than the Judicial Branch of the government, Richard Berman, director of labor law for the United States Chamber of Commerce, said "This has a chilling effect on an employer's exercise of his right to appeal and is thus a blatant denial of fundamental fairness." [U.S. News & World Report, 11/24/75]

  • The U.S. Chamber of Commerce Vigorously Opposed Occupational Safety Regulations and "led the fight to defeat the 1968 bill." In an article written between the initial bill supported by President Johnson and the second bill, that passed, supported by President Nixon, the New York Times reported: "The first legislation providing for a comprehensive nationwide system of health and safety standards was proposed last year by President Johnson. Strongly supported by labor, the bill ran into immediate and vigorous opposition from industry, led by the Chamber of Commerce of the United States." [New York Times, 12/10/69; New York Times, 3/19/70]
8. U.S. Chamber President Called OSHA "An Abysmal Failure." In 1980, Richard L. Lesher, President of the U.S. Chamber of Congress, charged, "OSHA at best has been a major disappointment, at worst an abysmal failure." "To date, there has been no solid documentation that OSHA has yielded any gains in safety or health," said Lesher. [AP, 4/1/80]

7. U.S. Chamber Spokesman Compared Employer Mandates to Jumping on a "Runaway Train." In 1989, U.S. Chamber Spokesman Frederick J. Krebs was asked by the Washington Post about employer mandated coverage and said, "Health-care costs are out of control -- so being forced to provide these benefits is like being told to jump on a runaway train." [The Washington Post, 4/13/89]

6. Referring to Mental Health Parity Legislation, Chamber Officials Said Personal Tragedy is a "Poor Way to Make Legislation." Complaining that opposing Republicans on mental health parity legislation put them in an awkward position, Neil Trautwein, manager of health care policy for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce said, "It's tremendous to have someone with the stature of Pete Domenici or Alan Simpson get up and describe these personal tragedies, but it's often a poor way to make legislation," says Trautwein. "An emotional argument late in the night is not the way to make policy." [The Washington Post, 6/19/96]

We thought we'd save the best for last, so: be sure to read the "top 5" quotes, after the break.

Tags: chamber, chamber of commerce, family medical leave, family medical leave act, federal government, health and safety standards, healthcare, healthcare bill, healthcare costs, healthcare reform, labor, mental health, mental health parity legislation, OSHA, richard berman, right-wing, U.S. Chamber of Commerce, workplace health and safety

Continue reading Top 10 Historical Chamber of Commerce Quotes Against Healthcare.
1
SEIU

Service Employees International Union
Change to Win Federation USA
Canadian Labour Congress
1800 Massachusetts Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20036
© SEIU | Privacy Policy

Take Action

  • Tell Congress to Act on Health Insurance Reform: 1-866-311-3405
  • Text 'SEIU' to 787753 for mobile updates
  • Tell the U.S. Chamber: Let People With H1N1 Use Paid Sick Time
  • Write Congress: Support the Employee Free Choice Act
  • Become an organizer
  • Follow SEIU on Twitter
  • Join our Facebook Group

Featured Video

On the one year anniversary of the election of Barack Obama, we stand on the precipe of real, progressive change. And after coming this far down the road to fixing health care, we can't let up now.
Employee Free Choice

SEARCH SEIU.org

 

MOST POPULAR

  • Our Union
  • Healthcare
  • Members
  • Jobs
  • Local
  • Blog

ACTIVE TOPICS

andy stern anna burger bank of america banks big banks chamber of commerce congress economic recovery employee free choice act healthcare healthcare crisis healthcare reform home care ken lewis president obama seiu union unions workers working families

TAKE ACTION

  • Register for email updates
  • Sign up for SMS alerts
  • Become an Organizer

STAY CONNECTED

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • youtube
  • flickr

rss RSS FEEDS

  • All site content
  • Blog posts
  • Releases
  • » all feeds

MEMBERS

  • Benefits
  • Scholarships
  • Your Role as Steward
  • Institute for Change
  • Financial Service Program
  • Member Political Organizers
  • Financial Officer Training
  • Safety and Health
  • What Is Pandemic Flu

JOIN US

  • Jobs
  • Internships
  • Become an Organizer

OUR UNION

  • Contact
  • Fast Facts
  • A Closer Look
  • How Unions Help
  • Get Local
  • Legislative Scorecard
  • Press

LEADERS

  • Andy Stern
  • Anna Burger
  • Mary Kay Henry
  • Gerry Hudson
  • Eliseo Medina
  • Dave Regan
  • Tom Woodruff

HEALTHCARE DIVISION

  • Long Term Care
  • Hospital Systems
  • Nurse Alliance

PROPERTY SERVICES DIVISION

  • Stand for Security
  • Justice for Janitors

PUBLIC SERVICES DIVISION

  • State/Local
  • Mental Health
  • Disabilities
  • Education
  • Child Care/Head Start
SEIU

Service Employees International Union
Change to Win Federation USA | Canadian Labour Congress
1800 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20036
© SEIU | Privacy Policy